Materials for teachers 6.1: Illustration of the policy cycle model – how can we reduce the number of car accidents?
Living Democracy » Textbooks » Taking part in democracy » Part 2 – Taking part in politics: settling conflict, solving problems » Unit 6: Government and politics » Materials for teachers 6.1: Illustration of the policy cycle model – how can we reduce the number of car accidents?Concepts and key questions | Notes |
0. Topic What is the issue? |
How can we reduce the number of car accidents? |
1. Problem Who sets the agenda? |
Minister of the Interior: more accidents. Young drivers – inexperienced, reckless. Males of all ages – too much alcohol. Motorists’ club: more cars on the road; taxes not used for improving road network. Environmentalists: CO2-emissions rising, oil supplies running out and becoming more expensive – support alternatives to car transport. |
2. Debate Who is involved? |
Everyone agrees on reducing car accidents. But there are different interests and goals involved in the debate: Minister wants to put pressure on reckless drivers. Motorists want better conditions for car drivers. Environmentalists are worried about global warming. |
3. Decision What is the outcome? |
The government decides to introduce two bills: Heavier fines for speeding, lower alcohol limits; more traffic controls. Four-lane highways are to be standard within five years. |
4. Implementation How is the decision implemented? |
More traffic controls, particularly in the evenings and at weekends. Highway extension and improvement scheme is scheduled, first roads under construction. |
5. Opinions Which individuals, protagonists, groups, etc. support or criticise the outcome? |
Motorists welcome construction scheme, question controls (more fines – more funds?) Environmentalists deeply disappointed. Demonstrations in the capital. Discussion: found a new green party? |
6. Reactions How do they react? (Individually, collectively) |
Environmentalists hold demonstrations in the capital. Discussion: found a new green party? Truck drivers complain of delays on highways. Minister reports 15% drop in accident figures within 12 months – maintains that success proves his policy right. |
7. New problem or Policy termination Does a new debate begin on setting the political agenda? Is it the same problem or a new one that is under discussion? Or has the decision led to a solution that ends the process? |
Minister: no new steps need to be taken. Observe development, discuss situation in 12 months. Environmentalists: alarming rise in CO2 emissions. Complaints by beer brewers: sales drop by 10%. Jobs at stake. Industry demands speeding up of road construction scheme. … |